Timber Creek Pizza




(920) 648-4288

(920) 648-4277


134 E Lake St,
Lake Mills, WI 53551

View On Google Maps


Visa, Master Card

Open Hours

Mon – Sun. 10:00 Am – 10:00 Pm

Found on Facebook

Timber Creek Pizza Co, Lake Mills, WI. 609 likes | 44 talking about this | 527 were here. We hope you enjoy your experience at Timber Creek as much as we. .

We need to apologize to our regular customers if you tried to patronize our restaurant Friday night between 5 and 7. A group of around 40 vacationers, without calling ahead, unexpectedly filled our restaurant and made it nearly impossible to give good service to our customers. We are working on a way to avoid this happening again. In our 30+ years in the business this was certainly a new one! Thank you for your patience. Ron and Betsy

Happy Fathers Day! Don’t forget to bring dad down and “buy” him his free ice cream cone today! Grandpa too!

We’re back open on Sundays! Business as usual, delivery star, ts at 5:00 like always! Stop in and try all the flavors of ice cream-19 to choose from! Fresh squeezed lemonade is back for the summer also!

We’re looking for an energetic, friendly delivery driver! Part-time, hours are 5-9 through May, then 5-10 for the summer. Great way to earn $10-15.00 an hour or more! Apply in person at the store if you’re interested. Just have to be 18 or over and have your own car and insurance.

Happy Mother’s Day to all the moms out there! We’re offering free single scoop ice cream cones for all Moms again this year! Our hours are 2-9 on Sunday. Hope everyone has a wonderful weekend!

Sundays are Ice Cream and Smoothie only days! Beginning May 3rd Timber Creek will be open from 2-9pm for ice cream and smoothie sales only (take-n-bake pizzas as well). Some of the new Cedar Crest ice cream flavors are becoming quite popular (Pirates Booty and Superman particularly). Sassy Cow Blueberry Cheesecake is still my personal favorite. Cedar Crest’s flavor of the month is Daily Grind, a coffee flavored ice cream with caramel ribbon and chocolate covered espresso pieces. Sounds pretty good and should be in later today. Enjoy the beautiful weather this weekend with family and friends!

Likely the last weekend for a skate in beautiful downtown Lake Mills. Stop in and say hello after some great family time in the park!

Spring is almost here! Stop in for a scoop of your favorite flavor ice cream-we have 17 to choose from! It’s never too cold for ice cream!

Wow! What a great day it’s been! The park was rollin’ today (well actually more like sliding) with big crowds. Thanks to all who stopped in. The Knickerbocker cone was a great success we’ll remember to do again next year. We did hear a rumor from one of our customers today that Timber Creek was closing!! Help us put an end to that wild rumor, it couldn’t be further from the truth. Thanks to you we just finished our best year ever and we’ve had quite a few great ones before this too!! Lake Mills has supported us well and we appreciate it!

Knickerbocker Day in Lake Mills!! Come on down and check out the many ice sculpture or take a skate on our Norman Rockwellian rink in the park. Snow shoes will also be available to try out in the park along with lots of other family friendly activities. Enjoy the day and try some walk around specials like a Knickerbocker ice cream cone for only a buck, or a nice warm pizza slice (lunch time only) or maybe a couple of tacos. We serve up some great chili as well! Get outside in this great weather!

Going to have to close early today (5PM). Too dangerous to have employees drive over from Waterloo to work or have a driver out delivering. Safety first. Have a great time watching the game tonight. Gotta root for New England on this one.

Have a funny feeling it will be a slow delivery night (a lot of business savvy went into that deduction!). Come on down, mention this post and get free garlic bread with your pizza (today only).

Phone service out right now!! Sorry. Don’t know why I switched to Charter Communications. What a joke!!

Hope everyone had a wonderful Christmas with family and friends. We sure did! We close at 7PM tonight (New Years Eve) so stop in early and pick up a take-n-bake pizza for that late night celebration or New Years day bowl game. Mention you saw this on facebook for $2.00 off any take-n-bake pizza today and tomorrow (open at 11AM, delivery star, ting at 5PM) only. Celebrate well but safely tonight!

All gift cards are 10% off now till December 23! They make great stocking stuffers, gifts for that special teacher, or anyone who enjoys great pizza, subs or ice cream! Just a heads-up: we will be closed on December 24-25, open at 10:00 on December 26th. We hope everyone has a very Blessed Christmas!

Happy Thanksgiving! We will be closed Thanksgiving day, be sure to stop in the night before and pick up a take-n-bake pizza! Give Mom a break from all the baking and cooking! We still have “Pumpkin Pie” ice cream-it’s delicious on a cone or in a shake. Our Christmas flavors are coming soon.

We’re happy to announce we’ve chosen Cedar Crest Premium Ice Cream to be our primary ice cream here at Timber Creek (with a sprinkling of a couple popular Sassy Cow flavors as well)! Stop in and try our new flavors-“Pumpkin Pie”, “Mississippi Mud”(mocha flavored with fudge swirls and chocolate cookies), “Pirate’s Booty”(caramel ice cream with, m&m’s, and chocolate cookies), “Superman” ( blended cherry, blue raspberry, and vanilla ice cream) a favorite with the kids.

It’s been awhile since we’ve updated our page-we had one of our busiest summers ever here at TimberCreek Pizza! Thank-you for choosing us for your pizza and ice cream cravings! We’ll miss our lake visitors and hope to see them again next summer!

Summer is here! Cool off with one of our fruit smoothies, ice cream malts and shakes, or the best root beer floats in town! Too hot to cook tonight? Let us do the baking and we’ll deliver a fresh-baked pizza to you! Stop in and try one of our 16 flavors of ice cream today! We now feature Sassy Cow ice cream!

It’s official.Smoothies are on the menu!! Finally. Try one of our 9 flavors. Verry Berry, Berry Mango, Strawberry, Strawberry Mango, Mango Dream, Tropical Breeze, Skinny Elvis, Mocha, and Banana Creamsicle. All made with REAL FRUIT. They are tasty!!

I had moderate expectations before stopping at Timber Creek, expecting the pizza to just be okay. I was blown away by ho. w good the pizza was! I typically don’t enjoy thinner pizzas and usually choose thicker pizzas with crust but this pizza had the right amount of cheese and toppings. I forgot quickly devoured the delicious pizza. The staff were also very friendly and the restaurant itself has pleasant interior decor.

We love going to Timber Creek! Great pizza, sandwiches, salads, & ice cream!.

Found on Twitter

Jeffrey Dahlberg
@ jdahlberg1
Lake Mills, WI
Ice cream (@ Timber Creek Pizza in Lake Mills, WI) https://www.swarmapp.com/c/k6XMLGwJ2rq

@ abdiasprates
Lake Mills, WI
Im at Timber Creek Pizza (Lake Mills, WI) https://4sq.com/KcM16s

Eli Wedel
@ eliwedel
Timber Creek Pizza
I just ousted @
x3_samantha as the mayor of Timber Creek Pizza on @
foursquare! https://4sq.com/b86eLl

Dan Dean
@ DblD75
Timber Creek Pizza
Picking up pizza for the family. (@ Timber Creek Pizza) https://4sq.com/OMEojg

Also Known As

Timber Creek Pizza Co

Please Leave a Review for Timber Creek Pizza

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Filed under Pizza, Restaurants